Above the Fold
The increasingly scrutinized area of advertising and marketing has a wealth of legal hurdles. When creating content, advertising professionals and companies often find themselves in hot water with various regulatory agencies, such as the Federal Trade Commission. In this blog, our team of seasoned media and trademark attorneys address emerging trends and issues in this complex area.
Attorneys Daniel Schnapp, Lisa Karczewski and John Wait cover issues relating to art litigation and finance, specifically art recovery, art preservation, art as collateral and valuation of art. They also discuss recent trends in the art market.
IP Spotlight Blog
Intellectual property is often the lifeblood of a company. As an experienced IP and registered patent attorney, Jim Singer keeps you up-to-date with the legal and business aspects of intellectual property and other intangible assets on his IP Spotlight blog. Covering topics such as licensing, due diligence, acquisition, compliance and risk management associated with patents, trademarks, copyrights and trade secrets, IP Spotlight provides insight, commentary and tips regarding recent legislation and developments in the industry.
Recent Blog Posts
- Anticipated Oral Argument Finally Heard This morning, the United States Supreme Court heard the long-anticipated oral argument in the Lee v. Tam trademark dispute. The issue in the case, as reported on the SCOTUS blog, is as follows: “Whether the disparagement provision of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. 1052(a), which provides that no trademark shall be refused registration on account of its nature unless, inter alia, it ‘[c]onsists of . . . matter which may disparage . . . persons, living or dead, institutions, beliefs, or... More
- Richard Polsky Art Authentication Offers New “Preliminary Opinion Service” Richard Polsky writes: As the owner of Richard Polsky Art Authentication, I’ve always believed that authenticity is the bedrock of any art transaction, which seems to have been proven out by the constant stream of related articles in the New York Times. During the last six months alone, we’ve been treated to the spectacle of the Knoedler gallery scandal for selling fake canvases by Jackson Pollock, Mark Rothko, Robert Motherwell, and others. Then there was the dealer Mary Boone pulling a... More
- DOJ and FTC release new Antitrust Guidelines for Licensing of Intellectual Property Updating policies that had been on the books for more than two decades, the U.S. Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission recently issued new Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property. The new Guidelines include several updates that reflect changes in the law since the 1995 guidelines were issued. For example, the new Guidelines now permit intellectual property license agreements to explicitly include provisions on resale price without being per se illegal. (Instead, price restraints in licensing agreements will now be analyzed... More
- Smithsonian American Art Museum Offers America InSight Tours For Blind And Visually Impaired Art Enthusiasts I was very inspired after reading this recent online NPR article on blind and visually impaired art enthusiasts being able to “see” and experience works of art at the Smithsonian American Art Museum in Washington, D.C. through uniquely guided tours. The museum offers America InSight tours twice a month led by specially trained docents to blind and visually impaired visitors. During these specially guided tours, the dozen or so volunteer docents use verbal descriptions of artwork as well as other senses in... More
- Federal Circuit: obviousness requires a clear and explicit explanation The Federal Circuit recently vacated a Patent Trial and Appeals Board (PTAB) decision that found obvious several claims of a patent application relating to methods for re-configuring icons on a touch-sensitive display. In In re Van Os (Fed. Cir. Jan. 3, 2017), the court’s decision focused on the PTAB’s failure to provide sufficient reasoning for the rejection, rather than the question of whether or not the claims were in fact obvious. The claims related to a user interface for a touch-sensitive display that would enter... More
- Polish Government Signs Agreement To Purchase Significant Private Art Collection In recent art world news, on December 29, 2016, the Polish government signed an agreement with the privately owned Princes Czartoryski Foundation to purchase the Czartoryski art collection, which is recognized as one of Europe’s most significant private art collections. The family foundation has administered the collection since its inception in 1991. The Czartoryski art collection includes 250,000 historic manuscripts and documents, some of which were previously owned by Polish kings. The treasured collection also includes 86,000 museum artifacts of which... More
- How long does it take for the USPTO to issue a patent or register a trademark? (2016 edition) At the end of each fiscal year, the USPTO releases a Performance and Accountability Report, with statistics about patent and trademark allowance rates, average pendency, and other details. The USPTO recently released its Performance and Accountability Report for Fiscal Year 2016. This means that it’s time for IP Spotlight’s annual review of the question: “how long does it take to receive a patent or trademark registration?” To answer that question, here are a few highlights from the USPTO’s FY 2016 report: Patents: The USPTO continued a five-year trend of... More
- FTC’s Order on “All Natural” Advertising Copyright: farakos / 123RF Stock Photo Earlier this month, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) issued a decision against California Naturel, Inc. related to its advertising of “all natural” sunscreen on both its website and the product packaging itself. On its website, California Naturel was not only advertising its sunscreen as “all natural” but was describing the sunscreen as containing “only the purest, most luxurious and effective ingredients found in nature.” The FTC found that this advertising conveyed that California Naturel’s sunscreen... More
- Who should be listed as inventors in a patent application? 49458832 – inventor This is a question that all patent applicants must answer before filing a patent application. However, applicants often answer the question without fully understanding the criteria for “inventorship.” Applicants often simply presume that the inventors listed on an invention disclosure, or the authors of a publication, will be the inventors. This is not necessarily the case, since inventors of an invention and the authors of a document can be (and often are) different. The consequences of failing to correctly identify the... More
- The First Amendment and Trademark Licensing at Public Universities: NORML Rules Apply Next week (12/14/2016), in a marble tiled courtroom in frosty St. Paul, Minnesota, a panel of judges of the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals will wrestle with a question that is both as new as the campaign to legalize marijuana and as old as the First Amendment: When can a public university protect its brand, and its valuable trademarks, from being associated with viewpoints or messages that it rejects? In the case of Gerlich v. Leath (8th Cir., No. 16-1518), a... More
- What Happens in Vegas Stays in…Albany, NY? Trademark Office Rejects New NHL Team’s Nickname as a Trademark The newest NHL franchise, set to debut in Las Vegas next year, might be considering other names for the team after the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) rejected the hockey team’s proposed trademark, “VEGAS GOLDEN KNIGHTS”. In an Office Action issued this week (Dec. 7, 2016), an examining attorney preliminary rejected the mark “VEGAS GOLDEN KNIGHTS” because it was too similar and likely to be confused with the mark used by the College of Saint Rose, “GOLDEN KNIGHTS OF... More
- German Art Dealer’s Heirs Sue German State of Bavaria Over Alleged Nazi-Looted Art in Bavarian State Paintings Collection As recently reported in the New York Times, the heirs of Alfred Flechtheim, a prominent German art dealer and collector, brought suit in federal court in Manhattan earlier this week against the German state of Bavaria over alleged Nazi-looted art works. The heirs argue that the German state of Bavaria has refused to return art works that were looted by the Nazis before World War II. The Flechtheim heirs seek the return of eight paintings by artists Max Beckmann, Juan Gris... More
- Berlin Returns Nazi-Looted Sculpture to Rightful Owners In recent art world news, a Nazi-looted sculpture has been restituted to the rightful owners by the City of Berlin. The looted art is a marble sculpture by Reinhold Begas entitled Susanna (1869-72) and the rightful owners are the heirs of the former publishing mogul Rudolf Mosse. At the turn of the century, Mosse was one of the three wealthiest men in Berlin. According to The Art Newspaper, Mosse’s “palatial neo-Baroque home on Leipziger Platz was filled with paintings, sculptures, antique furnishings... More
- It’s December 1: time to update your DMCA agent designation 14240670 – copyright If you operate a website that accepts user-generated content, it’s time to contact the Copyright Office. Many online service providers (OSPs) accept user-generated content. Examples include e-commerce websites that accept product reviews, news sites that publish user comments on posted articles, social media sites that permit users to share photos or videos, and even blogs who post comments from other users. It can be very difficult for an OSP to determine whether user-generated content was created by the user who posted it, or whether... More
- What’s in a Name? Not a Trademark Registration, At Least Christopher P. Beall writes: Although a rose “by any other name would smell as sweet,” (Romeo & Juliet, Act II, sc. 2, ln 48), there just aren’t any trademark registrations to be had in a person’s name, at least not without the person’s written consent. So the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office recently reminded a trademark applicant who had applied for a trademark registration for the mark “LOVE TRUMPS HATE,” in connection with clothing. Copyright: silvia / 123RF Stock Photo In an Office... More