Blog – Fair Housing Defense

http://fairhousing.foxrothschild.com/

Scott is the founder and editor of the firm's Fair Housing Defense Blog, which offers discussion and insight on fair housing compliance and other areas of interests to apartment owners and management companies as well as professional management employees.

Recent Blog Posts

  • Some Thoughts on Fair Housing and Smoking   A friend reached out to me to ask questions about HUD’s Smoke Free public housing initiative and for some general thoughts on smoking in apartment homes. So, here goes. There is no “right” to smoke in a rental home. Smokers are not a protected class under the federal Fair Housing Act (FHA) or its state law counterparts. While some have tried to argue smoking is addictive and, as such, should qualify as a disability, to my knowledge no court has so... More
  • Occupancy Standards and Fair Housing: A Short Summary   Occupancy standards are an issue which come up from time to time. On the one hand, a family certainly should have the right to decide the size of the apartment home they need and/or can afford.  On the other hand, management has a legitimate health and safety right to put a reasonable limit in place.  We do not want, and the law will not support, eight people living in a one bedroom unit.  The issue, of course, is where those two... More
  • Some Further Thoughts on Medical Verifications for Emotional Support Animals A couple of interesting emotional support animal medical verification questions have hit my desk over the past month. First, recall that case law on the issue of permissible credentials of a medical or health care professional is a bit unclear. Individuals who are licensed by a public regulatory authority (such as a state) to provide medical care, therapy or counseling to persons with disabilities certainly qualify. This includes, of course, medical doctors, physician assistants, psychiatrists, psychologists, and many social workers.... More
  • Will a Subsequent Purchaser of a Property Built After 1991 Be Liable For Accessibility Issues Related to Design & Construction of the Property? As all of us in the property ownership/management business know, communities get bought and sold from time to time. Indeed, a property can be sold many years (even decades) after it was first designed and constructed. Effective in properties designed and/or constructed from 1991 on, the Fair Housing Act (FHA) requires that all multifamily construction meet a specified level of accessibility for individuals with disabilities. As a part of the law, the FHA has seven “safe harbors” that design and construction... More
  • What Happens When the Federal Fair Housing Act Conflicts With a City or County Ordinance? While many apartment communities are “pet friendly” and welcome animals, almost every community has restrictions concerning, for example, certain breeds and/or weight limits for pets. In addition to the community policy on animals, many local jurisdictions similarly ban some dog breeds pursuant to a county or city ordinance. The question that comes to my desk is what happens when a resident submits a request for a service or companion animal as a reasonable accommodation pursuant to the federal Fair Housing... More
  • Do Emotional Support Animal Medical Verifications Last Forever? A legitimate question from leasing office professionals I get from time to time is: “We approved an emotional support animal for a resident two years ago. Does that approval continue indefinitely or can we seek a supplemental medical verification from time to time?” My answer is that there are any number of disabilities for which we grant a reasonable accommodation but for which medicine, treatment, surgery, or even the passage of time can have cured or helped cure such that... More
  • Best Practices Concerning The Fair Housing Act and Sexual Orientation Discrimination   Earlier this month we noted that a federal court in Colorado ruled that the Fair Housing Act (FHA) prohibits discrimination based on sexual orientation (although sexual orientation is not contained in the text of the statute). In that case, the district court judge concluded that ownership could not deny housing to a resident simply because the resident fails to adhere to gender stereotypes by being attracted to or married to a member of the same sex. As the case then... More
  • Some Thoughts on Advertising and Fair Housing Advertising your property is a good way to get apartments filled. But marketing a community can create a handful of fair housing challenges concerning the use of advertising.  First, remember that advertising is covered under the Fair Housing Act (FHA). When you advertise, do it in a way to reach as many demographic groups as possible. For example, when using people, be certain your advertising copy contains individuals of multiple races. Does that mean you cannot show a family of... More
  • Federal Court Concludes That LGBT Individuals Are Covered By The Fair Housing Act Back-to-back posts concerning the Fair Housing Act (FHA) and federal courts. Last week, in what I believe is another decision of first impression, a federal district court judge in Colorado concluded that the FHA prohibits discrimination against LGBT individuals. While the FHA prohibits discrimination because of sex (added as a protected class in 1974), familial status (1988), and/or national origin (1968), the statute says nothing about sexual orientation or gender identity and the issue had been in question for some... More
  • Does a Fair Housing Act Claim Survive the Death of a Party Raising the Claim? A Federal Appellate Court Says Yes. In a case of first impression (at least as far as I can tell), in an opinion issued last week, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit evaluated (and answered) the question of whether a Fair Housing Act (FHA) claim survives the death of a party. The facts involved an emotional support animal request and whether the condominium board had appropriately responded to the request. Before reaching the merits, however, the Court addressed an uncommon (and sad) issue... More