John represents individuals, partnerships and companies in diverse legal matters including complex commercial litigation, bankruptcy litigation and franchising issues. He represents both franchisors and franchisees in litigation and general corporate matters, including advice respecting Franchise Disclosure Documents, franchise agreements and related contracts. In addition to his litigation practice, John serves as trusted advisor to several companies and individuals, assisting his clients in developing a carefully coordinated approach to identify and address legal issues effectively and efficiently. He believes that a carefully coordinated approach to legal services is necessary not only to help his clients solve their legal problems but also to help his clients become more successful.
John’s broad background in litigation matters, in both federal and state courts, includes cases involving contracts, partnership and shareholder agreements, trade secrets, restrictive covenants, trademarks and copyrights, construction, antitrust, employment, protection of creditors’ interests in bankruptcy and governmental oversight of regulated industries.
Among his professional successes, John has:
- Successfully represented a franchisor of outlets providing emergency and regular maintenance services for the over-the-road trucking industry in a lawsuit in the Southern District of Florida involving violation of noncompete and nonsoliciation clauses of a terminated franchise agreement.
- Represented a franchisor in the insurance adjuster industry in the process of terminating a franchisee that was in violation of their franchise agreement. Defended the franchisor in a countersuit for allegations of fraud under New York law, to the satisfaction of the client.
- Served as co-counsel for the parent developer of the third largest auto dealer management software in the United States. In this case, licensed distributors of the software objected to termination, claiming the existence of perpetual right to renew their software license and distribution agreements on the same terms as the original agreements. Successfully convinced the arbitrator that the license and distribution agreements were of indefinite duration and therefore terminable by the parent developer after a reasonable period of time.
- Executed a litigation plan that resulted in a negotiated settlement in which the stated desire of the membership of a non-profit corporation to merge with the firm’s not-for-profit client was realized despite the trenchant and dogged opposition of the board of directors. The litigation effort included the coordination of actions in two different counties, the removal of recalcitrant board members, and the protection of assets that the objecting board sought to alienate, as well as enlisting the support of the Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare and Attorney General’s Office.
- Represented a pre-eminent not-for-profit organization as an interested party opposing the bankruptcy petition of another non-profit serving individuals with intellectual disabilities, mental health needs and behavioral issues. After an evidentiary hearing, the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania dismissed the bankruptcy petition and issued an opinion published at 473 B.R. 641 stating the opposing party’s actions were in bad faith.
- Obtained a $12 million federal jury verdict in a breach of contract action involving unpaid commissions owed to a clean coal technology company.
- Obtained affirmation from the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in an opinion published at 614 F.3d 57 of an award of summary judgment in favor of an auto racing sanctioning body in an antitrust case of first impression involving single tire rules in the auto racing and race tire industry.
- Favorably resolved claims of software copyright infringement brought by our client against a former franchisee.
- Obtained a nearly full recovery of amounts owed to a manufacturer that supplied stadium seating for PNC Park, the Pirates baseball stadium.
- Resolved favorably claims against the general contractor of a baggage conveyor system at the Pittsburgh International Airport.
- Obtained an injunction against a former vice president of sales and chief engineer who had abruptly left their employment and started a new division at a competing company.
- Obtained the dismissal of a suit brought by a property owner against a national supplier of flood plain insurance in a case of first impression.
- Resolved favorably numerous preference claims brought against creditors in bankruptcy proceedings.
- Resolved successfully claims prosecuted against a company violating a client’s trademark registrations.
Beyond Fox Rothschild
John is a U.S.A. Swimming Official, serving as a Starter, Chief Judge and Stroke and Turn Judge. He also serves on the Age Group Committee for Allegheny Mountain Swimming, one of 102 regional affiliates of U.S.A. Swimming.
John is an Appointed Governor, Chair of the Alumni Clubs Committee and member of the Executive Committee of the Georgetown University Alumni Association, as well as a former President of the Georgetown Alumni Club of Pittsburgh.
John presently serves as a Member of the Audit Committee and Bankruptcy and Commercial Law Section of the Allegheny County Bar Association (ACBA) and has previously served as the Chair of the ACBA’s Federal Court Practice Section and on its Nominating Committee.
John previously served as a member of the Parents Advisory Council of the Campus Laboratory School of Carlow University, which is an independent Catholic school serving children in pre-school through grade eight.
John is the editor of the firm's Franchise Law Update blog, which highlights not only the regulatory aspects of franchising but also diverse topics such as business finance, employment, litigation and the protection of intellectual property including trademarks and copyrights. He also regularly records podcasts on a variety of topics.
Franchise 101 - PowerPoint
John presented at the University of Pittsburgh’s Joseph M. Katz Graduate School of Business on the ins and outs of franchise law.
Arbitration Provisions and Alternative Dispute Resolution in a Changing Legal Landscape - PowerPoint
John presented on selecting arbitration and the best practices regarding the types of provisions to address the number of arbitrators, scope of discovery, and permissible motions.
Honors & Awards
- Named a “Legal Eagle” by the Franchise Times (2014-2020)
- Named among the Pennsylvania "Super Lawyers" in the area of Business Litigation (2015-2019)
- Named to "Pennsylvania Lawyers on the Fast Track" by The Legal Intelligencer and Pennsylvania Law Weekly (2009)
- Recipient of the Georgetown University Reed Alumni Service Award (2008)
- Named a "Pennsylvania Rising Star" by Philadelphia Magazine and Law & Politics Magazine (2005-2008, 2010, 2011)
- Named to the Order of the Barristers by the faculty of the University of Pittsburgh School of Law (1997)
- Named a "Legal Player" by 1851 Franchise (2018)