Patrick Egan Successful Before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Pro Bono Post-Conviction Death Penalty Appeal

February 12, 2016 – In The News

Fox Rothschild LLP Partner Patrick Egan was recently victorious before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in his pro bono representation of an individual who has been sentenced to death on a conviction of first degree murder.

In a landmark opinion, the court addressed the prohibition on the execution of the intellectually disabled pursuant to the US Supreme Court case of Atkins v. Virginia, agreeing with defense counsel that an individual’s rights under Atkins could not be waived by the individual when he was in disagreement with his counsel as to his own intellectual disability.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court remanded the case back to the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas for full consideration of the Atkins claim to determine whether the defendant’s death sentence should be vacated due to intellectual disability.

Egan has represented this defendant for more than 15 years during the course of his post-conviction appeals.